2002
St. Leger Dosage Preview
by Steve Miller
A review of
the Dosage figures reveals that there are very few strong candidates in the
staying category for the Classic generation.
Those
of you who have seen the Racing Post Weekender would be advised to ignore
Nick Mordin’s findings which are misapplied, present some incorrect figures,
and are not even consistent with himself.
Kazzia
(Zinaad) jumps out as the one with required stamina (although I understand she
won’t line up) 1-1-8-3-5 = 18 DI = 0.50 CD = -0.56. She is the only one with a
negative centre of distribution getting 8 stamina points (5 of them
Professional) from both side of her pedigree – from her Mill Reef-Shirley
Heights top line and from Nijinsky and Vaguely Noble (both fourth generation dam
side). Solid chances on stamina grounds, but I always think fillies are
vulnerable in this.
The
others have profiles more in line with the Derby distance. Balakheri, Bollin
Eric (somewhat surprisingly due to the speed influences on his dam side) and
Mamool come out next best in terms of stamina potential:
Balakheri
(Theatrical) 3-1-21-1-2 = 28, DI = 1.07, CD +0.07
Bollin
Eric (Shaamit) 5-2-8-5-2 = 22, DI = 1.00, CD +0.14
Mamool
(In The Wings) 7-2-14-5-2 = 30, DI = 1.14, CD +0.23
Bollin
Eric gets his stamina from his Crepello-Busted top line, passed down through
Mtoto and Shaamit. While Balakheri has only three Stamina points his central
concentration of a massive 21 Classic points will help his case. Nick has
incorrect figures for Mamool, who must be on the short list.
Mordin
argues in the Weekender that – “when you eliminate the horses by
Sadler’s Wells, who are unlikely to stay the Leger trip, you are left with a
shortlist of Ballingarry (who Mordin singles out as the one to take the
beating), First Charter, Kazzia and Mamool”. This is an odd thing to say since
Ballingarry is by Sadler’s Wells and Mamool by Sadler’s Wells’s son In The
Wings.
While
Sadler’s Wells is not an out-and-out staying influence himself (being an
influence for middle-distance stamina C/S) he is also capable of throwing up
Gold Cup winners, so a St Leger winner is of course possible. However, the likes
of Sholokhov and Ballingarry have pedigrees more appropriate to the Derby.
First
Charter’s
damsire is Shirley Heights so he could come into it although his sire’s side
doesn’t help:
First
Charter (Polish Precedent) 3-6-17-2-4 = 32, DI 1.21, CD +0.06
Mr
Dinos
(Desert King) should not be entirely ruled out despite having no stamina points
at all, as he has a high number of Classic points (17). Highest (Selkirk)
has a similar chance to Mr Dinos – not compelling.
Bandari
(Alhaarth), the probable favourite for Saturday’s race, has too low a points
total for his Dosage reading to be accurate. You must rate his chances according
to your own view of him. His trainer, Mark Johnston, maintains he is the one to
beat. His damsire has an AWD of just 8.9f (but from a small sample) and Hail To
Reason 9.9f. For me he is not certain to get the trip although if he does he is
probably good enough to win. Nick says that Bandari fails the Dosage test
“miserably”, but does not appreciate that he has not got a high enough score
for it to be meaningful (if you need an example of this look a Double
Trigger’s Dosage before and after the inclusion of Ela-Mana-Mou as an extreme
stamina influence). Viceregal is the only ‘off-Dosage’ influence that could
help him, but I don’t know enough about that stallion to comment (apparently
he has a ‘balanced speed’ influence which roughly conforms to Classic).
However,
as we have seen there are no real out-and-out stayers (with the exception of
Kazzia) so Bandari ought to make the frame.
I
would advise the ratings experts to look to the highest rated of Balakheri,
Bollin Eric and Mamool and go with that one. Mamool looks a tempting
each-way bet at the moment (16/1 is available).